Despite the roller coaster for equity markets recently, investors might be pleased with returns so far this year. Especially so for Canadians, with the S&P/TSX Composite now up over 8% year to date, and Canadian energy having one of the strongest quarters in a decade. At times, sticking with a winning trade can be the right approach. It is the basis of momentum, after all. This isn't always the case, especially when it comes to cyclicals. Your gut might not be screaming it's time to trim energy, but it may be worth considering a trim. In our view, the Hormuz blockade and supply disruption represent real and material risks. We don't dispute the severity, but the big moves in the energy market have already priced in much of this risk, and in turn produced something more dangerous for investor portfolios. Just like the classic Tom Clancy thriller Clear and Present Danger, the hero's problem isn't the enemy, it's that his own side doesn't realize how exposed they are. Canadian equity portfolios face a similar plot twist. Just as we’re getting this Ethos prepared to publish, the Strait of Hormuz has reopened, and oil prices have dropped 10% in a single session. What follows was written before that headline, but the thesis holds. If anything, this energy market move is proof of concept.
The Accidental Bull
We were constructive on equity markets heading into the year, but after such a strong 2025 viewed the odds of Canadian markets having a similar strong start in 2026 as slim. With high sector concentration, there are only so many levers the market has to pull to generate genuine strength: Financials, Materials and Energy. Back in January we advocated for maintaining energy exposure during the Venezuelan selloff despite fears of a supply glut in the first half of the year. That call was right, though for entirely the wrong reasons.
Year-to-date the S&P/TSX Composite is up about 8.3%. The chart below is a sobering visual. The S&P/TSX Composite Index isn't a diversified right now, it's been a two-sector trade. Energy (45%) and Materials (43%) account for roughly 87% of the entire TSX year-to-date return. Everything else is a rounding error, besides the drag of Technology. Considering how few would have predicted energy's dominance this year, we'd classify the Canadian market as the accidental bull.
During bull markets, rebalancing is one of those boring exercises that doesn't really feel like it's going to generate real returns. But after such strong performance, the energy weight in the TSX has risen to levels that demand attention. Looking at E&Ps, Integrateds and Pipelines only, the benchmark weight sits at 15.2%. Pipelines and midstream remain the biggest single sub-sector weight, while higher-beta producers now account for over half the sector.
The chart below breaks out energy weights by sub-sector across two popular Morningstar categories, the S&P/TSX Composite Index benchmark and the Purpose Core Equity Income fund. Canadian Dividend and Income funds average 18% energy exposure, with many of the largest funds and ETFs in the category carrying upward of 30%. Now most of this exposure is in the pipelines, but they still carry a higher weight in E&Ps than the S&P/TSX Composite Index. Canadian equity funds on average hold just 12.7%, well less than the TSX which sits at just over 15% total. Currently, the Purpose Core Equity Income fund holds just 13.3% exposure, after steadily reducing its energy weight over the past month.
Here's where it gets uncomfortable. For many Canadians in or approaching retirement, portfolios tilt heavily toward dividend and income mandates. These are the clients who are most risk-averse, yet they likely carry the heaviest energy weight. The clients who can least afford a sharp retrace have the most exposure to one.
When a single sector dominates returns this completely, the risk profile has changed. Cyclicals are called cyclical for a reason. There are boom times, and these are followed by periods of leaner returns. We're already seeing this play out on both sides of the border. Since the market bottomed on March 28th, energy has been among the worst performing sectors in Canada at approximately -4%. In the U.S. the pattern is even starker, with the S&P 500 Energy Index dead last at -10%. Meanwhile many other sectors are seeing terrific strength. In Canada, Tech hardware is up approximately 35%, Diversified Financials are up 16% and the gold trade appears to back on with Materials up 11%. In the U.S. Tech is leading big time, followed by consumer stocks particularly those hit by high oil prices. The rotation is already underway. The question is whether as an investor you choose to actively participate or just watch.
The equity market is already voting with its feet. The oil market is telling a similar story. The volatility in spot oil has baked a clear and present danger premium into futures markets. Spot WTI spiked from $60 to nearly $120 and has already pulled back approximately 29%. Most of the violence was in front-month contracts. December futures barely flinched, rising modestly from $58 to $77. The front-month premium peaked at 55% on April 3 and collapsed to just 23% within weeks. Trimming while the premium is still elevated may makes sense rather than waiting for the next compression.
Backwardation of this magnitude may be unlikely to persist, as it may reflect short-term hoarding behaviour rather than a structural shift in supply and demand. When the premium is driven by fear and logistics rather than a structural change in supply and demand, it can compress. In our view, the question is not if but potentially when this compression occurs. The spot/futures gap is the market telling us two different stories. The panic-driven premium presents a potential opportunity to reduce exposure. Today’s 10% drop on the Hormuz reopening is what that compression looks like in practice. The front month premium is still there, but is now well off of the highs.
The Active Edge
As much as rebalancing is a practice in risk management, it's also how you build the next leg of returns. Based on our view, we have been trimming energy over the past month, effectively monetizing the panic premium and redeploying capital into sectors where valuations have been compressed, cash flows are stable and earnings expectations are actually moving higher. Oil is already off its highs. The year to date as of April 20 2026, gain has compressed from nearly 100% to roughly 60%. Portfolios that haven't trimmed are giving back performance in real time.
Actively trimming and taking profits is a statement of discipline. We aren't predicting when the Strait of Hormuz reopens, when gas prices will get back to $1.30 per litre, or when there will be peace in the Middle East. The range of outcomes is so wide and dependent on so many variables that holding elevated exposure at this point may reflect complacency rather than conviction. The move that's already happened in the futures curve is a telling us that the danger premium baked into energy markets is already dissipating. From our vantage point, as well as the market's, on-again off-again talks are enough to move on.
The danger was clear and present. The premium was there for the taking. In our view, this morning's move in energy markets could be followed by further volatility. The danger premium will likely widen and compress again as headlines shift. The key is to be on the right side of that volatility, not hostage to it.
— Derek Benedet is a Portfolio Manager at Purpose Investments.
(The investment activities, portfolio holdings, and transactions referenced herein reflect the views and decisions of Purpose Investments and may not be applicable to all clients. Depending on your investment mandate and the sub-advisor managing your account, the information contained in this publication may not be applicable to your specific portfolio.)
The content of this document is for informational purposes only and does not provide investment, legal, accounting, or tax advice, nor does it constitute a recommendation or an offer to buy, hold, or sell any financial products. The information is not tailored to any investor’s circumstances, is provided “as is,” and may change without notice. Past performance is not guaranteed and values may change frequently.
Harness Investment Management Inc. (“Harness”) makes no warranties and is not liable for any loss or damage arising from use of this document, its information, or third‑party sources. All content is owned by Harness and may not be used or reproduced without prior written consent. This document is for personal, non‑commercial use only and is not intended for jurisdictions where its distribution would be unlawful. This publication is produced by Purpose Investments Inc., an affiliate of Harness Investment Management, registered as a Portfolio Manager and Exempt Market Dealer. For more information, please visit https://www.harnessinvest.ca/disclosure/disclaimer.